Skip to content

Fort Myers, Florida

Bad faith

When the handling is the problem

Slow answers, lost paperwork and low offers that never move can be more than a bad month. Sometimes they're a pattern.

A policy is a promise to deal fairly with a claim. When an insurer ignores letters, changes adjusters again and again, or offers less than its own file supports, how it handled your claim becomes part of the case.

We keep a dated record from the first call so a pattern, if there is one, is easy to see. We don't use the term lightly: many slow claims are only slow.

What we keep track of

  • Every date you called, wrote or sent something

  • Who you spoke to and what they said

  • What the insurer asked for, and when it asked

  • Each offer, with the reason given

  • Letters that arrived late, or never

A hand holding down a stack of printed pages beside a pen

Signs worth writing down

None proves anything alone. Together they can.

  • Silence

    Calls and letters go unanswered for weeks.

  • Moving goalposts

    Each time you send a document, a different one is requested.

  • An offer with no math

    A number with no estimate behind it, or one that ignores your contractor's.

  • The file closes while you wait

    You find out only when you call to ask what happened.

A sample matter

  • Offer raised

    Eleven months of missed deadlines

    A dated record of unanswered letters led the insurer to reopen the file and re-price it.

    2025

These are sample matters, not promises. Every claim turns on its own policy and facts, and past results don't predict the outcome of yours. Dollar figures are what the insurer paid, before fees and costs.

Is the insurer's handling part of the problem?

Send us your dates and letters, even if they're a mess.